<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom">
<channel>
  <title>Ellis J. Alia</title>
  <link>https://ellisjalia.com/</link>
  <atom:link href="https://ellisjalia.com/feed.xml" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
  <description>Notebook of Ellis J. Alia</description>
  <language>en-gb</language>
  <item>
    <title>An Inclination towards Taste</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#an-inclination-towards-taste</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#an-inclination-towards-taste</guid>
    <pubDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="an-inclination-towards-taste">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#an-inclination-towards-taste">An Inclination towards Taste</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Nov 21, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="Spine photo of the Oxford Thesaurus" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/thesaurus.jpg" width="500">
	
	<p>I was unsuccessful in finding a quote by Descartes that I wanted to post. In my search for it, I found another, similar quote. It’s by French philosopher Antoine Arnauld; it’s on language being infinitely variable.</p>

<p>"It remains for us to examine the spiritual element of speech ... this marvelous invention of composing from twenty-five or thirty sounds an infinite variety of words, which, although not having any resemblance in themselves to that which passes through our minds, nevertheless do not fail to reveal to others all of the secrets of the mind, and to make intelligible to others who cannot penetrate into the mind all that we conceive and all of the diverse movements of our souls."</p>

<p>I have studied Arnauld briefly. I know he’s famous for his <a href="https://www.earlymoderntexts.com/assets/pdfs/leibniz1686a_2.pdf">correspondence</a> with Leibniz. I find his quote interesting, and it’s this claim that Descartes makes: with twenty-five or thirty alphabetical letters we can create sentences of infinite variety.</p>

<p>To improve my English, I went looking for books which could be of help. Besides the well-known Oxford Thesaurus, I also found the "Dictionary of Untranslatables".</p>

<p>I wrote down part of their entry on ‘talent’:</p>

<img alt="Handwritten note of talent entry in the Dictionary of Untranslatables" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/talent.jpg" width="500">
	
	<p>They write that, in French, like in English, the word ‘talent’ only designates gift or <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#abilities">aptitude</a>. But the meaning of ’talento’ in Italian, in addition to its denotation of gift or aptitude, also captures inclination and high aesthetic standards of taste.</p>
	
	<p>This entry on talent caught my eye, but I don't know why yet.</p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Song of Los by William Blake</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#the-song-of-los-by-william-blake</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#the-song-of-los-by-william-blake</guid>
    <pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="the-song-of-los-by-william-blake">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#the-song-of-los-by-william-blake">The Song of Los by William Blake</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Nov 12, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="William Blake’s frontispiece to The Song of Los" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/the-song-of-los.png" width="500">
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Walt Whitman's Scrapbook of Cultural Geography</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#walt-whitmans-scrapbook-of-cultural-geography</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#walt-whitmans-scrapbook-of-cultural-geography</guid>
    <pubDate>Sun, 08 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="walt-whitmans-scrapbook-of-cultural-geography">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#walt-whitmans-scrapbook-of-cultural-geography">Walt Whitman's Scrapbook of Cultural Geography</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Nov 8, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="A worn page of Walt Whitman’s scrapbook: a printed list headed “Names of the Arts and Sciences”, with handwritten notes pasted on" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/whitman-scrapbook.jpg" width="500">
	
	<p>These past twenty-four hours or so I’ve been looking at a digital scan of <a href="https://whitmanarchive.org/literary-manuscripts/marginalia-and-annotations/scrapbook_viewer">Walt Whitman’s "Cultural Geography Scrapbook"</a>. In the <a href="https://whitmanarchive.org/literary-manuscripts/marginalia-and-annotations/scrapbook_index">introduction</a>, they write:</p>
	
	<p>"In the years following the publication of the first and second editions of Leaves of Grass, Walt Whitman began compiling a scrapbook. It's unclear what purpose he had in creating the massive document, comprised of portions of textbooks, magazines, newspaper clippings, and manuscript notes—more than 1,000 individual text surfaces in total—all relating, in some way, to world history and geography. Whitman in these years was both searching for ways to extend the vision he had laid out in the first two editions of Leaves, and also working and drafting in a variety of other genres. What we do know is that, in the late 1850s, as the nation appeared more and more in danger of fracturing, Whitman created a document that, between two hardbound covers, brought the whole world together, a laborious and sprawling act of union—and a document that contained the seeds of several works that found their way into print in the following years, including a number of poems in the 1860 edition of Leaves of Grass."</p>
	
	<p>It made me chuckle that he had a “Names of the Arts and Sciences” page gluedon to his scrapbook because it reminds me of <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/concepts">my concepts page</a>.</p> 
	
	<p>One day in the not too distant future, I should also like to try my hand at making a scrapbook. With so many things to put in it, and to arrange this way or that, it could be interesting.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/walt-whitman">Walt Whitman</a> · 2 of 2 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#organic-growth" title="Organic Growth">previous</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Study Session 4</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-4</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-4</guid>
    <pubDate>Fri, 06 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="study-session-4">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-4">Study Session 4</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Nov 6, 2026</p>

<p>Now, does Aristotle consider the soul to be the organisation of the body?</p>

<p>This is Heinaman’s next key question.</p>

<p>The organisation of the body enables an organism to engage in certain types of behaviour.</p>

<p>Heinaman: in De Anima 1.4 Aristotle argues that the soul is not the organisation of the body.</p>

<p>Which Ancient Greek word (translated) would Aristotle use if he did think that the soul is the organisation of the body?</p>

<p>Arrangement<br> 
Mixture<br>
Proportion<br>
Combination<br>
State<br>
Condition</p>

<p>According to Heinaman, the first word does not appear in the De Anima - but the next four do.</p>

<p>There, Aristotle argues that the soul is not a mixture, proportion, or combination of bodily parts.</p>

<p>Heinaman then teases out these distinctions:</p>

<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: There are three things to be distinguished here. A combination of bodies is a juxtaposition of particles of the bodies which leaves the nature of the original particles intact. For example, I might throw sand and sawdust together in such a way that particles of sand and sawdust lie next to each other and are still particles of sand and sawdust. But when two bodies are mixed they act on one another in such a way that the natures of the original bodies are altered to a different nature – a kind of chemical reaction takes place. And the proportion is simply the ratio of the amounts of the mixed or combined bodies." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-4-aristotle-1.png" width="500">

<p>Heinaman vehemently defends Aristotle’s corner: it is useless to appeal to any of those notions as to the identification of the soul.</p>

<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: …of these. For every term X that might express the concept of organization in Greek, Aristotle denies that the soul is an X of bodily parts. The view that Aristotle considers the soul to be some organization of the body is false." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-4-aristotle-2.png" width="500">

<p>Prior, Heinaman highlights Aristotle’s argument that health, or other bodily virtues, *can* be identified with a harmony of bodily parts.</p>

<p>A state is defined as an arrangement of what has parts; a condition is a kind of state, and health is one such condition.</p>

<p>Health is an arrangement of bodily parts, a condition, and a state of the body.</p>

<p>But the view that the soul is some organisation of the body is false.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/aristotle">Aristotle</a> · 5 of 5 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-3" title="Study Session 3">previous</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>If the Body Paints the World Inside itself, What Paint Does it Use?</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#if-the-body-paints-the-world-inside-itself-what-paint-does-it-use</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#if-the-body-paints-the-world-inside-itself-what-paint-does-it-use</guid>
    <pubDate>Thu, 05 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="if-the-body-paints-the-world-inside-itself-what-paint-does-it-use">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#if-the-body-paints-the-world-inside-itself-what-paint-does-it-use">If the Body Paints the World Inside itself, What Paint Does it Use?</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Nov 5, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="Drawing of a mug of coloured pencils whose colours stream as a rainbow into the eye of a face drawn in outline" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/img_0966.jpg" width="500">

<p>"Knowing that all things have their emanations" - Empedocles, 5th century BCE</p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Organic Growth</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#organic-growth</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#organic-growth</guid>
    <pubDate>Mon, 02 Nov 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="organic-growth">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#organic-growth">Organic Growth</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Nov 2, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="Handwritten copy of Walt Whitman’s “Song of the Universal”: Come said the Muse, sing me a song no poet has yet chanted, sing me the universal. In this broad Earth of ours, amid the measureless gross and the slag, enclosed and safe within its central heart, nestles the seed perfection. By every life a share or more or less, none born but it is born, conceal’d or unconceal’d the seed is waiting." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/whitman-song-of-the-universal.jpg" width="500">
	
	<p>I've been meaning to read Walt Whitman's poetry for a while. While leafing through a copy of his complete poems, I was reminded what a giant of literature he was.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/walt-whitman">Walt Whitman</a> · 1 of 2 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#walt-whitmans-scrapbook-of-cultural-geography" title="Walt Whitman's Scrapbook of Cultural Geography">next</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Study Session 3</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-3</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-3</guid>
    <pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="study-session-3">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-3">Study Session 3</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 30, 2026</p>
	
	<p>It should be stated outright that Aristotle was a dualist with relation to the mind-body problem (Aristotle's position, as noted by Burnyeat 1995, is difficult to cohere with modern, Physicalist ideas).</p>
	
	<p>So what does this entail? Heinaman is explicit: Aristotle must believe that the soul is an immaterial entity.</p>
	
	<p>And what is the meaning of immateriality? For the soul to be an immaterial entity, it cannot be made of matter.</p>
	
	<p>But this is qualified since a materialist can still accept the presence of immaterial properties in an object without abandoning his materialism:</p>
	
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: …but clearly more is required. A materialist might believe that the structure or shape of some wooden object is an immaterial entity – it is not made out of matter – without abandoning his materialism. The shape, like weight or velocity, will count as a physical property, and this the materialist is happy to accept. Similarly, even if Aristotle accepted (1), he might think of the soul as a kind of physical attribute of the body and so not be what we would want to call a dualist. More is needed." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-3-aristotle-1.png" width="500">
	
	<p>In the <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2">last note</a>, I ended at Heinaman's claim that for Aristotle the soul is changeless because it lacks magnitude. Questioning this, Heinaman now writes:</p>
	
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: But why did he come to believe that a subject of change must possess magnitude? The answer can be found in Physics VI.4, 234b10-20. In any change there is a subject, starting-point and end-point of the change. The end-point of the change is the newly acquired feature; the starting-point is the feature lost in the change; and the subject is what persists throughout the change, what begins with the starting-point and finishes with the end-point." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-3-aristotle-2.png" width="500">
	
	<p>Aristotle's argument is the following: If a subject is changing from A to B (A is white and B is grey), B being the first thing the subject changes into, he cannot be in A for the whole, nor in B for the whole. If he is in A for the whole, then he is at the starting point of the change. Nor can the subject be in B for the whole because the subject would have changed and not be in the process of changing - becoming B.</p>
	
	<p>The subject must partly be in A and partly be in B. But this entails that the subject of change is divisible into parts. But the soul is a form, and forms are indivisble, the soul is changeless.</p>
	
	<p>And since Aristotle believes all matter is divisible and changeable, the soul is therefore immaterial. <p>And since Aristotle considers the soul to be a substance, the soul is an immaterial substance.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/aristotle">Aristotle</a> · 4 of 5 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2" title="Study Session 2">previous</a> · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-4" title="Study Session 4">next</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Study Session 2</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2</guid>
    <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="study-session-2">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2">Study Session 2</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 29, 2026</p>
	
	<p>Perhaps it might be better to begin with the name of this paper, the question the author puts forward, and his main claim.’ Aristotle and the Mind-Body Problem’ is a paper by Robert Heinaman published in the journal Phronesis in 1990 (Vol. 35: 1), pp. 83 - 102.</p>
	
	<p>The author’s main question, as stated on p. 84, is as follows:</p>
	
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: Nowadays the mind-body problem revolves around the question of whether psychological entities and laws are reducible to physical entities and laws (or eliminable altogether). There is no question of Aristotle’s wishing to reduce “psychic laws” to physical laws (or eliminate anything), so the relevant question with regard to Aristotle is: does he reduce psychic entities (such as souls and mental events) to material entities (such as bodies and physical changes)?" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-2-aristotle-1.png" width="500">
		
	<p>And his claim (from page 1):</p>
	
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: In this paper I will argue that Aristotle’s position on the mind-body problem is probably best characterized as dualism." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-2-aristotle-2.png" width="500">
		
	<p>What is the historical angle here? Heinaman cites Democritus, the first atomist, who claimed:</p>
	
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: Thus, for example, Democritus held the soul to be composed of fine spherical atoms which move, bump into coarser atoms constituting the body, and thereby cause it to move. And, of course, since Democritus’ atoms were material objects he had to say that the soul was a material object." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-2-aristotle-3.png" width="500">
		
	<p>Aristotle had claimed that the living and non-living are distinguished by the fact that the former possess movement and perception. And since it is the soul which distinguishes the living, the soul explains why living things are able to move.</p>
	
	<p>But Aristotle’s agreement is only partial; he agrees that the soul of a living thing explains why it moves, but rejects the mechanism proposed by Democritus.</p>

	<p>The reason for Aristotle’s rejection of the proposed mechanism I mention earlier in my <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-1">study session 1 note</a>: “…because the soul is a form, and all forms are immaterial, and hence changeless”.</p>
	
	<p>In writing the Physics, which came prior to the De Anima, Heinaman claims Aristotle altered his position on whether the soul undergoes change: “There we find a rather strange intermediate position where some but not all transitions between different qualities of the soul are changes”.</p>
	
	<p>What characterises Aristotle’s earlier intermediate position is that the soul only undergoes perceptual change:</p>

	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: What Aristotle wishes to prove in VII.3 is that alteration occurs in a subject – soul or matter – only with respect to qualities which are perceptible. If the qualities in question are not of that kind but are rather conditions, states or shapes, then the subject – soul or matter – transiting between them is not thereby altered. If the qualities are perceptible, then the subject – body or soul – is altered. Since the intellect is not affected by sensible qualities, it is only the perceptive part of the soul that suffers alteration." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-2-aristotle-4.png" width="500">
		
	<p>So when Aristotle wrote the De Anima, Heinaman highlights that he likely had thought out the issues prior to reaching his mature conclusion:</p>

	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: Rather, by the time he wrote De Anima he had more clearly thought out what was required of a proper subject of change and had concluded that such a subject could not lack magnitude. Believing that souls lack magnitude he had to conclude that souls are changeless." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-2-aristotle-5.png" width="500">
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/aristotle">Aristotle</a> · 3 of 5 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-1" title="Study Session 1">previous</a> · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-3" title="Study Session 3">next</a></p>
<p class="entry-meta">Referenced in: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-3">Study Session 3</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Study Session 1</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-1</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-1</guid>
    <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="study-session-1">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-1">Study Session 1</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 29, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: Why does Aristotle reject the possibility of a soul undergoing change? As Alexander points out, it is because the soul is a form, and all forms are immaterial, and hence changeless." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-1-aristotle-1.png" width="500">
		
<p>Heinaman’s claim here is that Aristotle rejects the idea that the soul undergoes change, because only material things undergo change.</p>
		
	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: …the soul as the subject of change. In the Categories the soul is the substance which is the proper subject for different kinds of qualities (1a25-26, 9b33-…" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-1-aristotle-2.png" width="500">
			
<p>Interesting.</p>

	<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: …changes. The intellectual part of the soul both acquires and uses knowledge but neither is an alteration – a qualitative change – in the intellect. But this is not due to any difference between soul and matter, for the perceptive soul does undergo alterations (244b10-12, 247a4-17, 248a6-9) and some transi…" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/study-session-1-aristotle-3.png" width="500">
	
<p>This seems right.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/aristotle">Aristotle</a> · 2 of 5 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#follow-your-intuition" title="Follow your Intuition">previous</a> · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2" title="Study Session 2">next</a></p>
<p class="entry-meta">Referenced in: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-2">Study Session 2</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Follow your Intuition</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#follow-your-intuition</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#follow-your-intuition</guid>
    <pubDate>Wed, 28 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="follow-your-intuition">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#follow-your-intuition">Follow your Intuition</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 28, 2026</p>
		
		<img alt="Passage from Heinaman’s paper: Many have thought, correctly, that Aristotle’s views on the intellect commit him to some sort of dualism with regard to the rational soul, but reject this as an accurate representation of his position for other types of soul – sensitive, nutritive, etc. My argument in section I rests on no assumptions about the soul peculiar to the intellect. Aristotle’s dualism regarding the soul holds for any kind of soul, including the souls of plants. However, section II deals only with psychic events which have the soul as a subject. Digestion and other actualizations of the nutritive soul are not mental events because the proper subject of digestion, for example, is the body alone." src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/aristotle-28-oct-2026.png" width="500">
			
<p>I don’t want to read this Aristotle paper - but I will. Because whenever I pass on something that I should have followed - but I return to later instead - I always find something valuable there.</p>
			
<p>Probably somewhere in this paper there's one line or one idea that will link up a series of disjointed ideas I have from other papers, and give them a road to communicate through.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/aristotle">Aristotle</a> · 1 of 5 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#study-session-1" title="Study Session 1">next</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Books from Yesteryear</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#books-from-yesteryear</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#books-from-yesteryear</guid>
    <pubDate>Wed, 28 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="books-from-yesteryear">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#books-from-yesteryear">Books from Yesteryear</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 28, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="Covers of Structures: Or Why Things Don’t Fall Down, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, Terry Pratchett’s The Colour of Magic, Paul Feyerabend’s Killing Time, and Alfred Bester’s The Demolished Man" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/yesteryear-books.png" width="500">
	
	<p>Throwback to the books I was reading in 2019. Structures, The Autobiography of Paul Feyerabend, and The Colour of Magic made a huge impression on me. Especially Feyerabend’s autobiography; it’s so full of warmth and interesting anecdotes. What I also found especially interesting was my compassion towards him, despite him having been conscripted in WWII to fight for the Nazi's.</p> 

<p>Structures is a surprisingly simple book, but it has a lot of depth. It changed my whole outlook.</p>

<p>Not much to say about The Colour of Magic - it’s a book that has to be experienced. I genuinely couldn’t believe how good it was.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/books">Books</a> · 2 of 2 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#wladlyslaw-reymont" title="Wladlyslaw Reymont">previous</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Abilities</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#abilities</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#abilities</guid>
    <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="abilities">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#abilities">Abilities</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 27, 2026</p>
	
	<img alt="Duelling menu from a Dragon Ball Z video game, with Trunks saying: “I’m here to test everyone’s abilities.”" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/trunks.jpg" width="500">
	
<p>When I was a kid, I used to watch Dragon Ball Z - an anime show about Goku, his friends, and their enemies. Goku is an interesting character - and there are some others besides him which are also interesting - because he’s an incarnation of the Holy Fool archetype.</p>

<p>Anyway, I mention all of this because in one of the games I used to play on the PlayStation 2, Trunks, one of the characters, says in the duelling section, "I’m here to test everyone’s abilities". For some reason this really speaks to me.</p>

<p>Maybe it’s because lately I feel like I’ve reached the limits of my abilities and I need to find a new path forward. It's tough...</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Referenced in: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#an-inclination-towards-taste">An Inclination towards Taste</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Wladlyslaw Reymont</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#wladlyslaw-reymont</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#wladlyslaw-reymont</guid>
    <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="wladlyslaw-reymont">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#wladlyslaw-reymont">Wladlyslaw Reymont</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 27, 2026</p>
	
	<img src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/thepeasants.png" alt="The Peasants by Wladlyslaw Reymont" width="500">
<br>
<p>Recently I was looking at a <a href="https://fivebooks.com/category/fiction/nobel-prize-literature-books/">list</a> of books by Nobel Prize winners in Literature, and was debating with myself as to which one to get. But then I realised that’s not a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nobel_laureates_in_Literature">complete list!</a></p>

<p>So after scouring Wikipedia, I bought The Peasants by Wladyslaw Reymont, who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1924.</p>
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/books">Books</a> · 1 of 2 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#books-from-yesteryear" title="Books from Yesteryear">next</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Learning in the Age of Agentic AI</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/updates#learning-in-the-age-of-agentic-ai</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/updates#learning-in-the-age-of-agentic-ai</guid>
    <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" id="learning-in-the-age-of-agentic-ai">
	<h3 class="entry-heading"><a class="entry-title" href="https://ellisjalia.com/updates#learning-in-the-age-of-agentic-ai">Learning in the Age of Agentic AI</a></h3>
	<p class="byline notop">Oct 19, 2026</p>

<p>I wanted to write a note about how I use agentic AI for learning. First because it’s novel (to me at least). And second in the hope that someone else finds it useful.</p>

<p>I use <a href="https://openclaw.ai">OpenClaw</a> – an agentic AI harness – that I connect to Anthropic’s Claude using metered intelligence via their API.</p>

<p>The process takes about an hour to set up (with help from AI), and now I’m able to chat with OpenClaw using Discord (WhatsApp, iMessage, etc, are also available). Using just my phone, I can write files to my computer, request files, move them, and so on.</p>

<p>First I’ll tell you about my reading process. I’m basically old-fashioned: I print things out, I underline important passages with a pen, I write marginalia notes, questions, and I make arguments as to whether I agree or disagree with the claims being made in the paper or book that I’m reading. In between, I take long walks to think about ideas, what they mean, how they might connect to other ideas, or how they fit into my broader worldview.</p>

<p>Once I make my initial pass, I add highlights and notes into the digital version of the paper on Zotero. But since human memory is not optimised for memorisation, this note-taking process tends to break down.</p>

<p>In 1885, the psychologist Ebbinghaus showed us there is a ‘forgetting curve’ – within a day or so after you learn something, your recall will drop significantly. This process continues unless something is done to reverse it, to ‘flatten’ the curve.</p> 

<p>Later, spaced repetition was developed as a way of slowing down the forgetting curve. You review information at increasing intervals (e.g. 10 minutes after, then at 1 hour, then 1 day, then 1 week, and finally 1 month).</p>

<p>This is where agentic AI comes in. Once I read a paper, I drop it into my Discord chat with OpenClaw and ask it to quiz me on the paper using Anki-style questions. Here’s an example exchange:</p>

<p>OpenClaw:<br>
“In <em>De Anima</em> II.5, Aristotle describes the move from having knowledge (first actuality) to exercising it (second actuality). Is this an alteration in the strict sense? Why does that matter for Sisko’s argument?”</p>

<p>Me:<br>
“It is not an alteration in the strict sense. Aristotle claims it is not an alteration, or it is an alteration of a different kind to that of material alteration. It matters for Sisko’s argument, that material alteration is necessary for thought and perception, because it raises doubts about proposed claims in the literature that DA II shows that material alteration is not involved in perception.”</p>

<p>OpenClaw:<br>
“<strong>Correct.</strong> You’ve got the main point: the move from first to second actuality isn’t an alteration in the strict sense (it’s more a perfecting or fulfilment). Your explanation of why it matters is also good. Some scholars take <em>De Anima</em> II to show that perception doesn’t involve material alteration, and Sisko wants to block that inference.</p>

<p>I’d tighten my own card to match your wording, because it was muddled. I’m marking it correct.”</p>

<p>And then on to the next question.</p>

<p>Using metered pricing, this process averages to about 10p per question. You could of course use an LLM through a web interface, but I personally like having the option of being able to point the agent to the PDF file in its sandbox directory.</p> 
	
<p>In addition, my review questions and answers are saved automatically, and OpenClaw messages me at spaced intervals.</p> 

<p>All in all, I’m very impressed with how well it works, and I’m excited to see how I can further leverage agentic AI to learn, while still retaining my good old-fashioned methods of working.</p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Libri di Bottega</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/posts/libri-di-bottega</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/posts/libri-di-bottega</guid>
    <pubDate>Tue, 07 Jan 2025 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" data-thread="Leonardo">
		<h1>Libri di Bottega</h1>
		<span class="byline">Jan 7, 2025</span>
			<p></p>
			<img src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-2025-header.png" class="center-image" width="500" alt="Da Vinci header">
				<p>
					<center>A selection of drawings from Leonardo da Vinci’s notebooks.</center>
					<p></p>	
					<p> "The senses are of the earth; reason stands apart from them in contemplation." – Leonardo da Vinci</p>
					<p></p>
					<p>‘Libri di bottega’ translates to something like ‘work books’ or ‘workshop’ books. Leonardo da Vinci obtained the practice of using ‘libri di bottega’ – notebooks that combine notes, sketches, models and records for consultation – during his training with Andrea del Verocchio.</p>	
					<p>In December 2024, I <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/posts/the-mind-of-leonardo">wrote about da Vinci’s view of the world</a>. In this post, I want to delve deeper into his notebooks.</p>
					<p>The libri di bottega are instruments for expression. Because of their flexible typology, it meant that da Vinci could use the workbooks as a repository for creative ideas, a place which could provide continuity for visual exercises and creative thoughts, and a means of practicing for fresh sketches. The workbooks are moreover anthologies of motifs, written reminders and sketches.</p>
					<p>Drawing was thus to be used as an instrument of cognitive investigation – to fix in place teaching furnished by experience; the suggestion of forms upon the mind; and the depiction of the curved and parallel lines which make up everything in the world. His drawings also play with hazy colours and outlines to depict distances; perspective was also given by colour, by the fact that colour fades in the distance.</p>
					<p>Sketching for him was a motive for ongoing thinking. He used them to derive life-like movement and gestures to communicate “atti mentali” – the mental acts of subjects.</p>
					<img alt="Three Leonardo drawings: head and shoulders of a Christ figure, a bald man in profile, and a roaring lion" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-2025-1.png" width="500">
					<center><p>Head and shoulders of a Christ figure (c. 1490-1495); bald man in profile (c. 1495); and roaring lion (c. ?)</p></center>
					<p>Drawings and sketches were “short signs” of bigger ideas, and hence why his uncultivated compositions placed a focus on the mental acts of figures, people and animals instead of a focus on the limbs. Leonardo writes:</p>
					<p>"Therefore, painter, roughly compose the limbs of your figures and first attend to the movements appropriate to the mental accidents (acts) of the animals who compose the story, rather than to the beauty of and goodness of their limbs."</p>
					<p>Da Vinci studied the dynamic rhythms of life, and the aboriginal forces of nature which destroy everything: waves, whirls, spirals, centrifugal and centripetal forces. He saw these as the vital values inherent in nature, as its creative impulses, and as its way of the continuous transformation of forms.</p>
					<img alt="Three Leonardo drawings: water flowing past obstacles and a whirlpool, a study of a horse, and anatomical studies of the rotation of the arm" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-2025-2.png" width="500">
					<center><p>Studies of water flowing past obstacles and sketch of whirlpool (c. 1508-1510); study of horse (c. 1503); and anatomical studies on the rotation of the arm (c. 1509-1510)</p></center>
					<p>Leonardo saw the world in terms of laws – ‘reasons’ that govern nature, and the mechanisms which underlie it. The relationship between cause and affect was always on his mind.

</p>
					<p>Leonardo referred to nature as the “mistress of all mistresses”. In order to make works of any significance, the artist should not imitate but only take nature as the standard. Nature, experience and direct observation were the cornerstones of his method. The principles which regulate nature were indispensable to his production of art.

</p>
					<p>He was also a student of metamorphosis; the changing aspects of the world. He saw the genetic proceedings in nature and as that which forms its history. His sketches depict a clear train of thought: scientific analysis and artistic synthesis both lend to each other. For instance, he understood geological processes as the “chain of the world”. He wanted to take as his task the investigation and visualisation of the productive forces of the world.

</p>
					<p>Da Vinci subjected everything to an inquisitive gaze. His drawings have vibrancy, dynamism, analysis of morphology; the definition of forms are subjects to his understanding of the laws of reality and perspective (e.g. the disappearance of figures as they recede into the distance).

</p>
					<p>He could give a sense of breadth of landscape; a breeze moving through the trees, and the roar and motion of the waterfall. Nature was thus to be observed not as a background to life’s happenings; but instead the very dynamic force which brings forth everything.

</p>
					<p>As the only Renaissance author to allude to sketchbooks, he deemed them important for close observations from nature. He revisited themes ‘ex novo’, meaning from the beginning, as is evidenced by his animal and anatomical drawings.

</p>
					<img alt="Three Leonardo drawings: the paw of a dog or wolf, the proportions of a dog’s head, and the proportions of a horse’s leg" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-2025-3.png" width="500">
					<center><p>Studies of the paw of a dog or wolf (c. 1480); study of the proportions of a dog’s head (c. 1497-1499); and study of the proportions of a horse’s leg (c. 1485-1490)</p></center>
					<p>Leonardo above all understood the necessity of technical spontaneity and virtuosity. He was aware of the role required by both the conscious and unconscious mind in the creative impulse. 

</p>
					<p>In the dazzling quick sketches that he produced, he allowed the creative imagination to be released through that process of rapid sketching and the brainstorming of ideas. He was also aware of the creative energy that is evident in an unfinished work of art. He owned a copy of Leon Battista Alberti’s work, De Pictura, in which Alberti says:

</p>
					<p>"It is advisable to avoid that decadence of those who, wanting everything to be free from every defect and everything to be too clean, in their hands the work becomes old and dirty before it is finished."</p>
					<p>For ultimately, Leonardo wanted to capture in his drawings the convergence of sensory perception and the phenomena and movement of the world. Hence why his drawings often do not provide too much detail, but instead allude to the fact that, in them, an inquisitive mind is subjectively investigating the world.
</p>
						
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/leonardo">Leonardo</a> · 2 of 2 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/posts/the-mind-of-leonardo" title="The Mind of Leonardo">previous</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Mind of Leonardo</title>
    <link>https://ellisjalia.com/posts/the-mind-of-leonardo</link>
    <guid isPermaLink="true">https://ellisjalia.com/posts/the-mind-of-leonardo</guid>
    <pubDate>Thu, 05 Dec 2024 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
    <description><![CDATA[<div class="post" data-thread="Leonardo">
		<h1>The Mind of Leonardo</h1>
		<span class="byline">Dec 5, 2024</span>
			<p></p>
			<img src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-collage.png" class="center-image" width="500" alt="Da Vinci collage">
				<p></p>
				<center>A few examples of Leonardo’s drawings, with self-portrait at age 60 in the centre. His notebook manuscripts are held in both public and private collections, notably by Bill Gates, the Biblioteca Ambrosiana, and the Royal Collection Trust.</center>
				<p></p>
				<p>“…the greatest geniuses sometimes accomplish more when they work less, since they are searching for inventions in their minds, and forming those perfect ideas which their hands then express and reproduce from what they previously conceived with their intellect.” – Leonardo da Vinci</p>
				<p>The great Renaissance biographer and painter Giorgio Vasari wrote of Leonardo da Vinci that, in the last moments of his life, he rebuked himself for having “offended God and mankind in not having worked at his art as he should have”.</p>
				<p>Da Vinci completed only about 20 paintings, but he left behind over 7,200 notebook pages, an accomplishment that reflects his unequaled range of intellectual passions.</p>
				<p>He was born in 1452, near the town of Vinci, just outside of Florence, Italy. He was an illegitimate child to a notary father and a peasant mother, and initially received training in the master workshop of Andrea del Verrocchio. Until his death at age 67 in 1519, and despite his prodigious output, Leonardo owned little and hardly worked.</p>
				<p>He tended to move between projects, leaving many of them unfinished (the Battle of Anghiari being a prominent example). Sigmund Freud characterised this tendency as the encroachment and subsequent suppression of the artist by the scientific personality which distinguished his life.</p>
				<p>Yet, Leonardo’s skill and outlook earned him a great reputation, which only grew after his death, and it culminates in our understanding and appreciation of him as the archetypal Renaissance figure. This is what Vasari writes about the qualities exemplified in his work:</p>
				<p>"Nature so favoured him that, wherever he turned his thought, his mind, and his heart, he demonstrated with such divine inspiration that no one else was ever equal to him in the perfection, liveliness, vitality, excellence, and grace of his works."</p>
				<p></p>
				<p>Da Vinci had elegance, finesse and neatness, and he enquired with unparalleled genius into the unity of nature and its variety of astonishing patterns. What is it that made da Vinci’s mind special?
</p>	
				<p>To answer this question, it’s essential to examine the extent of his contributions to painting, anatomy and scientific drawing, neuroscience, and ultimately, the blueprint of the scientific mind.</p>
				<p>A full answer may not be possible to the aforementioned question. But nevertheless, unbundling and putting together certain ideas might reveal how the mind of that quintessential genius was always devising new things, and how we might be able to learn from him.</p>
				
				<h4>Leonardo as Artist</h4>
				<p>Da Vinci revered the sense of vision, and placed it as man’s highest sense. He described the eye as “the window to the soul”, and the most important basis of all experience. Vision’s role, beyond providing fundamental perceptual knowledge, involves the artist’s use of the faculty in faithfully interpreting nature:</p>
				<p>"The painter’s mind must of necessity enter into nature’s mind in order to act as an interpreter between nature and art."</p>
				<p>To peer into nature’s mind, Da Vinci understood that the artist must learn the laws of reality and its manifestations as perspective. He conceived of perspective as the seeing of an object behind a sheet of glass, and by which a pyramidal cross section is cut by the glass; thus all points of perspective can be expressed by point, line, angle, surface, and body. He also devised three branches of perspective:</p>
				<p>"…the first deals with the reasons of the [apparent] diminution of the volume of opaque bodies as they recede from the eye, and is known as Diminishing or Linear Perspective. The second contains the way in which colours vary as they recede from the eye. The third and last is concerned with how the outlines of objects [in a picture] ought to be less finished in proportion as they are remote."</p>
				<p>These laws of perspective were to be kept in mind so that only what could be seen with certainty was depicted as certain; that which was seen with difficulty was to be made indefinite. Lines were to be blurred and suggestively left open. His drawings were only made of outlines and hatching marks in accordance with those laws, and yet they convey unrivalled volume and dynamism.</p>
				<img alt="Leonardo’s perspective study of an architectural setting, with staircases, arches, horses and figures drawn over converging perspective lines" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-perspective.jpeg" width="500">
					<p></p>
				<p>Leonardo’s technique can thus be seen as a solution to the duality between abstraction, and a naturalistic interpretation of reality. This is best exemplified in some of his hydrodynamic and geological drawings.</p>
				<p>In them, he wanted to carry across the dynamic forces of nature, stones slowly shifting across the ages, as the roots of plants growing in the crevices were tearing those very stones out, moving them ever so slightly from the old place they once occupied. Water rapids rippling and creating vortices. In these images, amongst others, Leonardo shows that nature transforms everything.</p>
				<p>His drawings convey movement and the moving figure in a style that possesses exemplary confidence and control over artistic tools. As a student of reality, in which he placed supreme trust in the instruction provided by the visible world, he carefully studied figures using his cross-hatching technique.</p>
				<p>This allowed him not only to depict his close observations, but also to best old techniques in faithfully conveying distance, the intangible density of the atmosphere, and the idea that the world exists as a spatial continuum.</p>
				<p>Leonardo divided the science of painting into drawing and shading, and it was for him the “true knowledge and legitimate issue of nature”. There’s a further passage in which he explains his thought process as to how the artist should best consider painting:</p>
				<p>"…as subtle invention which brings philosophy and subtle speculation to the consideration of all forms – seas and plains, trees, animals, plants and flowers – which are surrounded by light and shade."</p>
				<img alt="Detail of Leonardo’s Saint John the Baptist: a smiling face framed by curly hair, emerging from darkness" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/saint-john-the-baptist-leonardo-da-vinci.jpeg" width="500">
					<center><p>A detail from Saint John the Baptist.</p></center>
				<p>This is a philosophy that is evident more so in the Mona Lisa and Saint John the Baptist, than any of his other paintings. About the former, read what Vasari had to say:</p>
				<p>"The eyes have the lustre and moisture always seen in living people, while around them are the lashes and all the reddish tones which cannot be produced without the greatest care. The eyebrows could not be more natural, for they represent the way the hair grows in the skin—thicker in some places and thinner in others, following the pores of the skin. The nose seems lifelike with its beautiful pink and tender nostrils. The mouth, with its opening joining the red of the lips to the flesh of the face, seemed to be real flesh rather than paint. Anyone who looked very attentively at the hollow of her throat would see her pulse beating: to tell the truth, it can be said that portrait was painted in a way that would cause every brave artist to tremble and fear, whoever he might be."</p>
				<p>To breathe life into portraiture, anatomical details and structure were to be carefully extracted from reality itself, so that the mouth and the lips may be joined to the face as a continuous surface.</p>
				<p>Only by seeing and learning from direct observation how each thing is formed can the artist learn to reproduce each part. And by faithfully combining parts that he has learnt how to draw, he may reproduce the whole. But he also knew that this process must be achieved step by step:</p>
				<p>"The organ of sight is one of the quickest, and takes in at a single glance an infinite variety of forms; notwithstanding which, it cannot perfectly comprehend more than one object at a time. For example, the reader, at one look over this page, immediately perceives it full of different characters; but he cannot at the same moment distinguish each letter, much less can he comprehend their meaning. He must consider it word by word, and line by line, if he be desirous of forming a just notion of these characters. In like manner, if we wish to ascend to the top of an edifice, we must be content to advance step by step, otherwise we shall never be able to attain it."</p>
				<h4>Scientific Drawing and Anatomy</h4>
				<p>Leonardo was a student of reality; being the first to draw in the open air, he inquired into the cause and reason of all visible things, and can be described as a visual empiricist. While he was knowledgeable of the scientific literature of his time and what had come before, he kept himself free and unconstrained by past thinkers. He accepted those things only which he could prove by the direct perception of his own eyes.</p>
				<img alt="Leonardo’s drawing of the Star of Bethlehem and other plants, with swirling leaves" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-star-bethlehem.jpeg" width="500">
					<p></p>
				<p>In his drawing, “The Star of Bethlehem”, he is able to depict the power of growth inherent in plants, the elasticity of twigs; and the correct observation and order of spiral shapes found in nature. There exists in them a combinatorial understanding of morphology and function of physiological principles that govern life. His drawings extract the “atmosphere of life” and make plants and animals look alive, since he is able to visualise the macro forces which we might characterise as the engine of life itself.</p>
				<img alt="Leonardo’s studies of cats in many poses: curled up, stretching, crouching and fighting" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-animals.jpeg" width="500">
					<p></p>
				<p>Leonardo thought of life as both a mechanism and organism. He thought of the earth as possessing a “spirit of growth”; and the soil as the flesh, its rocks as bones, limestone as the cartilage and “its blood, the springs of water”.</p>
				<p>The motion of animals, the major one found in nature he called “serpegiamento”, or snake-like. It is a movement that he studied extensively and can be seen in the animal drawings, from horses to cats and fantastical dragons.</p>
				<p>He used drawing to convey scientific knowledge (the empiricism aspect). Regarding the capturing of man in his anatomical studies, he warned against description without visualisation:</p>
				<p>"And you who wish to represent by words the form of man and all the aspects of his membrification, get away from that idea. For the more minutely you describe, the more you will confuse the mind of the reader and the more you will prevent him from a knowledge of the thing described. And so it is necessary to draw and to describe."</p>
				<img alt="Leonardo’s anatomical studies of the leg and other parts of the body, surrounded by his mirror-written notes" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-anatomy.png" width="500">
					<p></p>
				<p>Leonardo’s concept of drawing meant a new era for the human mind had emerged. Had his notebooks been published during his lifetime, or even the anatomical treatises he set out to complete but never did, the most profound revolution would have occurred in science. Yet, progress in anatomy was left to other great minds like Andreas Vesalius, with the publication of his treatise “On the Fabric of the Human Body in Seven Books”.</p>
				<p>On anatomy, Leonardo advised that the painter should be,</p>
				<p>"…thoroughly familiar with the limbs in all the positions and actions of which they are capable, in the nude. [Then he will] know the anatomy of the sinews, bones, muscles, and tendons so that, in their various movements and exertions, he may know which nerve or muscle is the cause of each movement and show those only as prominent and thickened…"</p>
				<h4>Contributions to Neuroscience</h4>
				<p>Beyond his pioneering work in painting, anatomy and scientific drawing, Leonardo wanted to prove that the mind has a physical basis. He wished to show the mechanisms by which the brain makes sensory stimuli intelligible, and thus show the functioning of the mind.</p>
				<p>A few of his drawings depict three ventricles in the brain, cavities filled with cerebrospinal fluid, the first being responsible for the processing of sensory stimuli; the second housing thought and the integration of the senses; and the last ventricle by means of which thought and sensation are imprinted into memory.</p>
				<img alt="Leonardo’s drawings of the human head, with the layers of the scalp peeled back and the brain’s chambers shown inside the skull" src="https://ellisjalia.com/images/da-vinci-neuroscience.png" width="500">
					<p></p>
				<p>The second ventricle is depicted as being in the geometric centre of the brain, thus denoting “the locus of the soul”. This for Da Vinci was the place where the senses came together to form the “sense communis”, or common sense, the seat of universal judgment:</p>
				<p>"The soul apparently resides in the seat of the judgment, and the judgment apparently resides in the place where all the senses meet, which is called the common sense."</p>
				<p>While this theory is known to be false, since we know the physical basis of the mind rests on electro-chemical communication between specialised neurons, it is nevertheless a triumph of his era, since he went beyond anything that had been put forward before.</p>
				<p>To conclude, let’s read an extract from Otto Benesch’s essay, Leonardo da Vinci and Scientific Drawing (1943) that captures some aspects of his genius (and the likes of which I hope humanity will see again):</p>
				<p>"This vision of cosmic grandeur reveals the deep intuition of the artistic genius. Leonardo’s scientific insight is unthinkable without his artistic imagination. The artist and the scientist are interdependent. Leonardo possessed not only the masculine sovereign and creative power, but also the feminine gift of highest empathy. He lived in the heart of things. His drawings prove that he felt like the object which he portrayed, that he identified himself with it. He looked at the world from the center, from the matrix, and it became diaphanous to him in an almost magic clearness. Thus, both intuition and divination served as guides for this greatest intellect among the artists in his scientific accomplishments."</p>
				
<p class="entry-meta">Thread: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/threads/leonardo">Leonardo</a> · 1 of 2 · <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/posts/libri-di-bottega" title="Libri di Bottega">next</a></p>
<p class="entry-meta">Referenced in: <a href="https://ellisjalia.com/posts/libri-di-bottega">Libri di Bottega</a></p>
</div>]]></description>
  </item>
</channel>
</rss>
